Weighing the Options

Project Managers Can Tip the Scales When it Comes to Proof-of-Concept Initiatives


By Marat Oyvetsky, PMP

In today's digital-first world, companies can't afford to make mistakes when they pursue major technology improvements. But with so many requirements and stakeholders, these improvements are not an easy endeavor. Sales meetings, technical capability demonstrations, and discussions about technical architecture, enterprise planning and pricing discussions all can drastically change the company's original desired concept. On top of it all, these decisions must satisfy the organization's needs for years to come and can drastically impact future business decisions.

With so much at stake, organizations need to test their options before committing to a particular solution. And it falls on project managers to guide stakeholders and participating vendors through pilot projects that validate final decisions. Beyond helping define how the technology will solve a business problem, here are three ways project managers can help lead organizations through a successful proof-of-concept (PoC) trial.


PoCs typically need only two or three vendors. Yet the industry is flooded with vendors of varying expertise—and they're often startups that rely on venture capital for funding. Project managers can lead a briefing that requires vendors to prove their financial health and business stability. This meeting reveals their funding sources, support system and resources. Your organization is making a huge investment, so having that financial snapshot can ensure the solution provider won't go out of business anytime soon.


The many siloed stakeholders will have competing interests. Project managers can work with all stakeholders and vendors to build a consensus on defined success and how it will be measured during the PoC. But having everyone on the same page doesn't mean cramming everyone in the same room. PoC meetings with all stakeholders present can become a disaster, because each stakeholder treats their own requirements as the most important. I prefer to meet with each stakeholder separately then create a centralized document or chart showing the success criteria for the whole organization. I have seen PoCs fail or stagnate because stakeholders got territorial. Divide and conquer is the key.


With a limit to scope and implementation, PoC timelines will be much shorter. Keeping all stakeholders on track in an accelerated environment calls for project managers to stay on top of all tasks and seek constant updates from the start. That means helping each vendor to plan for all requirements, making sure key stakeholders have all the information necessary to approve the design, and establishing a chaos-free environment for testing, review and final selection.



At the end of the day, project managers must facilitate a collaborative PoC. This is what defines project leadership—not simply marking tasks off a project plan, but shepherding stakeholders with competing PoC objectives toward a shared experience that yields long-term benefits. PM

img Marat Oyvetsky, PMP, is senior manager at Rackspace, San Diego, California, USA.



Related Content

  • Why Great Ideas Fail and How to Make Sure They Don't member content open

    By Vargas, Ricardo Viana | Conforto, Edivandro Carlos | Oumarou, Tahirou Assane To reduce failure rates and successfully deliver strategies in 2020 and beyond, organizations must overcome disruptive forces and flip posing challenges to opportunities and advantages. It all…

  • PM Network

    Vital Signs member content open

    Transforming horizon-focused strategic visions into here-and-now reality can't happen in a vacuum. Instead, project leaders must cultivate a deep understanding of the business, technological,…

  • Project Management Journal

    How Cooperation Reinforces Conflict over Time member content locked

    By Schweiger, Sylvia | Konlechner, Stefan W. | Güttel, Wolfgang H. Managing projects raises multiple tensions such as the need to balance cooperativeness and assertiveness. By adopting a process perspective, we analyze why a project group consisting of three…

  • PM Network

    A Leg Up member content open

    By Fister Gale, Sarah Startup success stories are legendary. Visions of Amazon founder Jeff Bezos selling books out of his garage, or Jack Ma scraping together money to launch Alibaba, inspire budding entrepreneurs…

  • PM Network

    Beyond Tech member content open

    Metric depiction of the evolving roles of the CIOs as digital technologies move to the heart of organizations.