Why project ethics matter

Leadership is built on trust. If the foundation is cracked, a project's future is in doubt


By Michael O'Brochta, PMI-ACP, PMP

ONCE, when a long-term client displayed an ethical lapse, I told him it violated my standards. Then I withdrew as the manager of one of his largest projects. Instead of terminating my contract, the client changed his behavior and also increased his business with my consulting company.

Project ethics matter, and this year's 10th anniversary of the PMI Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct is a good time to reflect on that. Not only do ethics allow us to act in a way consistent with our beliefs, they're a key to executing projects successfully. This is because ethics lead to trust, which leads to leadership, which in turn leads to project success.


A recent study conducted by Vrije University Amsterdam found that the more a leader acts in a way that followers feel is appropriate and ethical, the more that leader will be trusted.

And when people trust someone, they're more likely to follow him or her. As James Kouzes and Barry Posner write in The Leadership Challenge, “It's clear that if people anywhere are to willingly follow someone—whether it be into battle or into the boardroom, the front office or the front lines—they first want to assure themselves that the person is worthy of their trust.”

Once team members trust a project manager, they can begin to follow him or her. Establishing this leadership is key to solving a challenge that always bedevils project managers: managing people you don't have authority over.

In my case, the client saw me acting ethically, trusted me, then allowed my behavior to lead him toward more ethical behavior—and a successful project.

For another example of this process, look at Volkswagen Group. Last year, the German automaker acknowledged manufacturing and installing software to defeat elements of the emission control systems in 11 million diesel-powered cars. It's a massive scandal, a legal quagmire and a huge lapse in ethics, for which the organization has apologized. Many customers have lost their trust in the company. Stock prices and sales of Volkswagens fell drastically after the news broke.

Once team members trust a project manager, they can begin to follow him or her.

In spite of such negative consequences, ethical infractions abound in the workplace, and employees confront only half of the unethical behavior they see at work, according to Crucial Accountability: Tools for Resolving Violated Expectations, Broken Commitments, and Bad Behavior.

Joseph Grenny, a co-author of the book, says the more often people choose to stay silent, the more likely it is norms will shift, ethics will decline and organizations will suffer severe consequences. “While biting your lip may make your job easier in the short term, it does little to preserve productive working relationships and profitable organizations,” Mr. Grenny said in a statement. “That's why it's in every employee's best interest to hold colleagues accountable for unethical behavior.” pm

img Michael O'Brochta, PMI-ACP, PMP, is chair of the PMI Ethics Member Advisory Group and president of project management consultancy Zozer Inc., Roanoke, Virginia, USA.




Related Content

  • Project Management Journal

    The Effects of Megaproject Social Responsibility on Participating Organizations member content locked

    By May, Hanyang | Sun, Daxin | Zeng, Saixing | Lin, Han | Shi, Jonathan S. This study focuses on the effects of megaproject social responsibility (MSR) on participating organizations’ performance.

  • Project Management Journal

    Sifting Interactional Trust through Institutions to Manage Trust in Project Teams member content locked

    By Farid, Parinaz This article explores mechanisms to facilitate the development of interactional and institutional trust and explicating the interplay between those mechanisms.

  • PM Network

    Mandato para o amanhã member content open

    Como nenhum outro país, o País de Gales está reformulando a forma como os projetos se alinham com tudo, desde a sustentabilidade até as desigualdades raciais e de gênero.

  • PM Network

    Mandato para el futuro member content open

    Gales está planificando con anticipación, está remodelando cómo los proyectos se alinean con todo, desde la sostenibilidad hasta las desigualdades raciales y de género.

  • PM Network

    Mandate for Tomorrow member content open

    Like no other country, Wales is reshaping how projects align with everything from sustainability to racial and gender inequities.