Project management professionalism

it's all about mentoring!

Share to0

Conference PaperTalent Management, Resource Management22 October 2011

Walker, Loran W.

How to cite this article:

Walker, L. W. (2011). Project management professionalism: it's all about mentoring! Paper presented at PMI® Global Congress 2011—North America, Dallas, TX. Newtown Square, PA: Project Management Institute.

Mentoring is at the core of helping project managers new to the profession, as well as those who are changing knowledge areas within the discipline to gain experience in their fields. This paper assists mentors, mentees, and organizations who are considering a mentoring program. It suggests tools, techniques, and "best practices" to assist the "accidental project manager," students breaking into the profession, and those new to the profession on how to use mentors to help them progress in the profession. This paper also suggests what things a mentor may do to assist up and coming project managers.

Abstract

Mentoring is at the core of helping project managers new to the profession, as well as those who are changing knowledge areas within the discipline to gain experience in their fields. This paper will assist both mentors and mentees and organizations considering a mentoring program. This paper will suggest tools, techniques, and “best practices” to assist the “accidental project manager,” students breaking into the profession and those new to the profession on how to use mentors to help them progress in the profession. This paper will also suggest to the mentors what things they may do in order to assist up and coming project managers.

Introduction

“Project management mentoring is a critical project office activity. Most people seem to agree that the best way to train someone in project management is with on-the-job training.” (Kerzner, 2003, p. 18)
Mentoring is a suggested technique for successful project management and is one of the things that need to be done. Like many guides and standards the “what” is identified, whereas the “how” is not articulated. For example: “A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK® Guide) briefly mentions mentoring and coaching (PMI, 2004, p. 213), which can be considered socialization activities, but does not explicitly build them into tasks or processes. Other than mentioning mentoring and coaching, the PMBOK® Guide contains no direct reference to the transfer of tacit knowledge between individuals.” (Reich & Wee, 2006, p.19) Even so, there is also a wealth of “what” to be found in much of the literature on this topic.

Therefore, the concept of mentoring is not limited to assisting new project management practitioners in becoming knowledgeable about the discipline, but may also be used:

  • With “seasoned” professionals as well as new practitioners
  • As a leadership technique for project managers
  • On volatile or fast-paced projects
  • As a way of building a project management office (PMO)
  • As a standardized process
  • As an instrument of retention to minimize talent turnover
  • To introduce the new project
  • With an individual or a team
  • To be integrated into a project manager career path
  • To work on “soft skills”

Clearly, “mentoring” means many things; however, the definition of a mentor is “to give advice and instruction to (someone) regarding the course or process to be followed”. (Mentoring, 2011) However, a more detailed and helpful definition could be:

“Mentoring is a structured and trusting relationship that brings people together with caring individuals who offer guidance, support, and encouragement aimed at developing the competence and character of the mentee. Mentoring pairs a less experienced person with one who has experience and is willing to teach, coach, counsel, sponsor, and energize.” (Laughlin & Yopp, 2006, p. 24)

Types of mentoring involve one-to-one, team, peer, and with the advent of the Internet, E-Mentoring. There have been programs developed in which a university and a local Project Management Institute (PMI) Chapter have collaborated on giving students “real world” experience and evolving a certificate program in project management. (Poston & Richardson, 2011, p. 55)

The main point, though, is to achieve the transfer of knowledge from the “seasoned” professional to new employee(s), as well as articulating new processes, reinventing current processes, and improving the products of projects.

A Triple-Win Opportunity

A common theme in all the literature is the symbiosis of the relationship between the mentee, mentor, and the organization. It may be seen as a “win-win-win” relationship. The new employee is finding her or his way through the logistics of the new organization. The mentee wants to know the rules, learn what they can about their assignment, and fit in to the organization. In other words, the mentee has a need to “belong.” This is true of the new employee who has project management experience or has worked on a project as a team member yet needs to understand the culture of the hiring organization.

The “seasoned” professional helps the new employee understand the mission and goals of the organization. In addition, this professional may pick up a new thing or two from a pair of fresh eyes in the organization. The organization may reward the professional for the knowledge transfer.

The organization, in order to gain sustainability, must keep the costs low. With mentoring, costs are lowered by new employees ramping up quickly to becoming effective employees. By having a mentoring program, the organization shows interest in the new employee and limits employee turnover, which saves additional monies from being spent to hire and train new employees (Exhibit 1).

Symbiosis of Mentoring in an Organization

Exhibit 1: Symbiosis of Mentoring in an Organization

Guidance for Mentees

“It is in part coaching and mentoring provides for continuous feedback and links the individual’s current needs to the organisation’s mission.” (Keegan & Hartog, 2004, p. 609)

A new employee needs grounding in his or her new career assignment; however, not all organizations have mentoring programs available to new hires. A new hire, though, may take steps to find individuals who may help them understand the mission and goals of the company. Their immediate boss may be able to assist in this endeavor or a project manager and project team members may be able to point them in the right direction.

Here are some other suggestions on how to make first contact with a mentee or find out information:

  • Be attentive and open to new training initiatives/opportunities
  • Be attentive and open to new volunteer opportunities
  • Read the organization’s internal communications (newsletters, emails, etc.)
  • Attend organization’s social functions
  • Be observant during meetings on who the subject matter experts are and introduce yourself to them
  • Ask your boss who would be a good person to contact about a complex issue
  • See if there is a research arm of the organization or online resources to be tapped
  • Join professional societies (PMI, for example.) to get immersed in the discipline
    • Join a local PMI Chapter
    • Join a PMI Community of Practice

For organizations with established mentoring programs, the mentee should make sure he or she understands the ground rules of the engagement with the mentor. For example:

  • When is the best time to contact the mentor?
  • What is the preferred way to the contact the mentor?
  • What are the mentor’s expectations of you?
  • Is the mentor available on a “as-needed” basis or all the time?

The main point is that the prospective mentee has to become engaged in the organization’s culture from the beginning of his or her tenure. Pay particular attention if there is an orientation session to find out if there are mentoring programs for new hires. As previously mentioned, those familiar with project management tools and techniques will still need to understand the culture of the organization in order to be guided.

Guidance for Mentors

Suggestions range from working with groups to one-on-one relationships in regard to becoming an effective mentor. A mentor needs to know when to intervene and when to let the mentee do his or her work. The main objective is for knowledge transfer to occur so that the mentee feels confident in his or her new position. But this isn’t a one-way relationship, because the mentor will have his or her knowledge reaffirmed, may try new things, and learn from the mentee as well.
“A mentor must assume leadership and facilitate discussions to encourage contributions, to affirm commitments, and to attend to follow-up obligations. In such a collaborative environment, mentoring means more than one-on-one guidance between veteran and beginner; instead, mentoring is a group effort, involving practitioners with a variety of experience and providing an influential model for how colleagues work together as a matter of course.” (McCann, 2010, p. 112)

Peterson expounds upon various ideas on how a project manager may improve his or her craft. One of the most common analogies is the following:

The best project leader is a strong cheerleader.

• Impact—Hype, positive attitude, generous support, and plenty of smiles. Although this can offer an encouraging environment, the consistent upbeat approach may not always be applicable to the project situations experienced, may become annoying to others, or may merely result in only a marginal impact.

• Resolution—Look at project management as a mentoring opportunity. Work with team members through situations by applying clarifications and understandings to provide a good learning opportunity of what to continue to do in the future and what to change. When things go well, look for the strong foundation, steps, effort, and application of knowledge/experience that was applied and resulted in the accomplishment. When things do not go as planned, look for the components that resulted in failure to seek out the learning opportunity in a desire to improve similar situations within the future.” (Peterson, 2007, p. 64)

Being a mentor is a leadership position, but there is a subtlety to this role in that there is a fine line between directing work and encouraging new hires on how to do a task or job properly. The mentor position lies somewhere in between and the potential mentor needs to know the boundaries of the mentoring assignment.

Guidance for Both Mentors and Mentees

Within project management, one of the main documents to be generated is a team contract. This document stipulates the ground rules of the team in meetings and team member contact. A successful mentoring program should, like a team contract; elaborate on the expectations of both parties. Laughlin and Yopp suggest the following guidelines:

  • Provide time for a mentoring relationship to develop. Participants should meet frequently and on a regular basis
  • Establish a clear beginning and ending for at least phase one of the relationship
  • Identify a shared purpose and specific changes or improvements that are desired
  • Agree to an advocacy arrangement based on respect, listening, trust, and confidentiality
  • Identify mutual boundaries and roles (informative, facilitative, motivational, developmental, and behavioral)
  • Identify incentives for accomplishing purposes
  • Identify opportunities to withdraw, reflect upon and assess the mentoring relationship and terminate or realign for the future” (Laughlin & Yopp, 2006, p. 33)

Clear communications and expectations are needed in order to have a productive mentoring program. Both parties need to be aware of their responsibilities.

Guidance for Organizations

In a nutshell, a mentoring program may be looked upon as a sharing experience among many people, departments, and divisions of an organization. This sharing means that there is going to be open communications throughout the organization. Herzog shows the immense amount of information that is included when there is collaboration in an organization. There is a mentoring program as part of the organizational sharing. Such keywords as “Learning, Planning, Knowledge, Understanding, Information, and Goals are at the core of this diagram. (Herzog, 2000, p. 32)

As organizations become more project “savvy” and mature their processes, mentoring is one of the many tools the organization should consider using. (Dai & Wells, 2004, p. 525) When process improvement is part of the culture, a standardization of the mentoring program will occur.

When it comes to managing the mentoring program, Kerzner suggests that such a program should be on an “as-needed” basis. “The mentoring program could be done on a full-time basis or on an as-needed basis, which is the preferred approach. Full-time mentoring may seem like a good idea, but it includes the risk that the mentor will end up managing the project.” (Kerzner, 2003, p. 18) Having standards within a mentoring program may assist in mitigating the problem of a “seasoned” professional from taking over the reins of the project when it is not needed.

Also it would be presumptuous of the organization to assume that potential mentors will be willing to do the extra work involved in the mentoring process. A reward system should be considered to mitigate this issue with the “seasoned” professional.

“Examining the practices of an organization's novice and experienced IT project managers was revealing. We noted the disparity between their appreciation for training and use of electronic repositories when attempting to reuse knowledge. An organization might overcome these differences by incorporating factors into their reward system that provide incentives to employees to formally seek out and share knowledge or by implementing mentoring programs to help model desired behavior.” (Petter & Randolph, 2009, p. 54)

Following are some guidelines for management to consider when starting a mentoring program:

“Program planning and design will establish the following guidelines:

  • Program goals and expected outcomes for mentors, mentees, and the organization
  • When and how often mentors and mentees will meet
  • How long the mentoring arrangements will last
  • The primary purpose of the mentoring program
  • The assessment and evaluation process
  • Open lines of communication” (Laughlin & Yopp, 2006, p. 28)

Another author offers the following:

  • “Joint training;
  • trust building exercises between mentors and learners;
  • leadership and management education of learners by mentors in areas such as management style, organizational structure, and decision-making approaches;
  • audiovisual resources such as written guides, video and audiotapes, and role-playing training sessions;
  • career development need identification and task development exercises; and
  • regularly scheduled mentor/learner meetings.” (Gingerich, 2003, p. 511)

And, finally:

  • “The career path levels describe different skill levels
  • With raising career path levels, social and leadership competencies increase, accompanied by courses, workshops, on-the-job-training; less expertise and expert know-how is needed in the higher ranks
  • Integration of a mentoring model: mandatory support of project managers by higher-ranked project managers
  • Movement through the career path levels by proving competence and experience
  • Central capturing and provision of project managers’ careers for project and personal planning
  • Alignment of all organizational career paths (i.e., expert, leadership and project managers) to allow for a fair and transparent promotion policy in the organization .” (Holzle, 2010, p. 784) (Exhibit 1)

For the organization, the main point to remember is that a mentoring program may help with consistency of processes from one project to the next; it will help improve the bottom line by training and retaining employees.

“A mentoring program makes sense and saves money. It can lead to higher retention of employees, and it can also attract new talent by demonstrating an organizational commitment to professional development. The cost of replacing a current worker is estimated to be as much as two to three times the cost of retaining someone.” (Laughlin & Yopp, 2006, p. 26)

Conclusions

This paper was written in conjunction with a panel discussion held at the PMI North American Congress in 2011. The purpose of this paper was to lay a foundation for that discussion, but additionally offer information to new practitioners, “seasoned” professionals, and organizations that are contemplating the creation of a mentoring program.

Clearly, a mentoring program can bring added-value to any organization that implements one; however, there are logistics, communications, and subtleties that need to be addressed as a program is being planned. And, finally, on the issue of the mentoring relationship, Gingerich succinctly defines the importance of confidentiality in the relationship by saying, “It is important that both mentors and learners maintain the confidentiality of information shared as a result of this relationship. This means that the organization must also respect the confidential nature of the mentoring relationship.” (Gingerich, 2003, p. 512)

References

Dai, C.X., & Wells W.G. (2004). An exploration of project management office features and their relationship to project performance. International Journal of Project Management, 22, 523–532.

Gingerich, B.S. (2003). The mentoring relationship. Home Health Care Management & Practice, 15(6), 511–512.

Herzog, V. (2001). Trust building on corporate collaborative project teams. Project Management Journal, 32(1), 28–37.

Holzle, K. (2010). Designing and implementing a career path for project managers. International Journal of Project Management, 28(8), 779–786.

Keegan, A.E., & Hartog, D.N.D. (2004). Transformational leadership in a project-based environment: A comparative study of the leadership styles of project managers and line managers. International Journal of Project Management, 22, 609–617.

Kerzner, H. (2003). Strategic planning for a project office. Project Management Journal, 34(2), 13–25.

Laughlin, K., & Yopp, M.C. (2006). Mentoring makes sense: Try it. Journal of Adult Education, 35(1), 23–33.

McCann, T. (2010). Mentoring as collaborative effort. English Journal, 100(2), 110–112.

Mentoring (2011) In Merriam-Webster Learner’s Dictionary Retrieved from http://www.learnersdictionary.com/search/mentor[2]

Petter, S., & Randolph, A.B. (2009). Developing soft skills to manage user expectations in IT projects: Knowledge reuse among IT project managers. Project Management Journal, 40(4), 45–59.

Peterson, T.M. (2007). Motivation: How to increase project team performance. Project Management Journal, 38(4), 60–69.

Poston, R. S., & Richardson, S. M. (2011). Designing an academic project management program: A collaboration between a University and a PMI Chapter. Journal of Information Systems Education, 22(1), 55–72.

Reich, B.H., & Wee, S.Y. (2006). Searching for knowledge in the PMBOK® Guide. Project Management Journal, 37(2), 11–26.

© Dr. Loran W. Walker
Originally published as a part of 2011 PMI NA Global Congress Proceedings – Dallas/Fort Worth, Texas

Like what you just read?

Log in or register for a free PMI account to get access 
to even more articles like this one.

Offer from our training partner

Advertisement

Offer from our training partner

Advertisement

Offer from our training partner

Advertisement