Q+A

diplomatic relations

Share to0

ArticleStakeholder Engagement1 January 2003

PM Network

How to cite this article:

Q+A: diplomatic relations (2003). PM Network, 17(1), 44–45.
Reprints and Permissions – opens in a new tab

Project management experts comment on the question of managing client expectations while remaining realistic about time and cost. Advice includes thoroughly identifying stakeholders, linking scope and schedule, and developing trust.

img

Q: How do you manage client/customer expectations? How do you meet customers' quality or scope expectations while remaining realistic in terms of time and cost?

img

MICHAEL COOPER, PMP, MANAGEMENT CONSULTANT, WESTFORD CONSULTING, WESTFORD, MASS., USA

Project managers must factually point out the consequences of scope or quality changes as quickly as possible in a way that the customer can relate to. You have to help customers understand that they have a decision to make and that you can help provide them with the information to make an informed decision. Once they acknowledge that changes are decisions, that they understand and own the consequences of those decisions, you are making great strides toward managing their expectations.

Data for an informed decision come from maintaining a current model of the project's future (Keep your plan up-to-date!), upon which you can generate what-if models. Describing the consequences of the new model to the customer in terms they understand may require explaining additional tasks or longer task durations with associated cost and schedule impacts. If this is done well, customers come to trust your ability to help them make informed decisions. This on its own may not be enough to manage expectations, but if you do not understand and cannot clearly articulate the impact of change, you will have no chance to manage expectations.

img

RICARDO VIANA VARGAS, PMP, CO-CHAIR, GRUPO A&C, BELO HORIZONTE, BRAZIL

First, it is necessary to establish a trust relationship with the client, showing him your skills and commitment, which are linked to the project's objective, including all its dimensions, not only the product of the project.

You have to make it clear to the client that alterations in the scope or in the quality directly affect the project costs and deadlines. Also, confusing requisitions that clients make, trying always to attain the ideal situation may harm other aspects of the project.

One day, a project manager friend of mine said, “I can't stand it anymore. The more we evolve in projects, the more desires, new needs and eternal improvements come up. And needless to say, along with those desires we can see that we get closer and closer to deadlines, and the money is not enough to pay the expenses of our initial budget. How can I convince the client to analyze these changes?” I answered, “Try to understand that the good situation is the enemy of an excellent one, and it's no use having a perfect product with unreal costs or time to offer to the market. How about creating a project so that we can have the best factory of vinyl music albums in the world? Would you buy it?”

img

RODGER CLAWSON, PMP, PRESIDENT, RODGER CLAWSON AND ASSOCIATES, GRESHAM, ORE., USA, AND VICE-CHAIR, FINANCE, PMI RETAIL SPECIFIC INTEREST GROUP

I tailor my responses to the customer's industry so his customers are better able to hear him set and manage expectations. For example, when setting cost and time project expectations with elected officials, I use their election campaign as a model project. Since there is a fixed date, the outcome only can be altered by adding more cost. Once this example gets their attention, then I can have a better discussion about the constraints of cost, time, scope and quality.

In the retail world, where keeping operating costs to a minimum is key, I start the discussion from the cost perspective. In large retail establishments, saving a fraction of a penny on each credit card transaction can have a tremendous effect on the bottom line.

Since banks want to be known as stable institutions, I manage expectations in this industry starting from the quality perspective. Usually the financial institution has a mission statement that talks about stability. After that, I move to quality, then to cost, time and scope.

While successful client expectation management is a general skill of project managers, it is through our PMI Specific Interest Groups that industry specific approaches are shared and developed.

img

GREG STINE, SOFTWARE IMPLEMENTATION PROJECT MANAGER, COMPUTER PATENT ANNUITIES, JERSEY, UK

The best illustration related to customer service that I have experienced on one of my projects really demonstrates what not to do. A recent deployment of a correspondence management system in a Federal agency was running into continual snags due to incompatibility with the agency's standard Internet browser and operating system configuration. To make matters worse, the vendor did not have any configuration management processes in place.

While it was debatable where the problem originated, i.e., within the software or within the environment, the bottom line was that the mission-critical system did not function adequately. We approached the vendor with a proposal to “share the blame,” take steps to resolve the issues quickly and move on toward project completion. The agency was not looking to take advantage of the situation by placing the entire burden for resolution with the vendor; it just wanted some acknowledgement from the vendor that it was committed to finding a solution as part of a team.

Instead, we received the following response from the vendor's project manager: “You bought an off-the-shelf system. You've gotten what you paid for. If it doesn't work, too bad!”

While this is a simplistic summarization of the incident, the vendor plainly did not appreciate that, contractual environment or not, projects require teamwork, cooperation and a sense of shared responsibility among all stakeholders if they are to be successful.

BRENDAN MORAN, PMP, PROJECT MANAGER, CIRCUITCITY.COM, CIRCUIT CITY STORES, INC., RICHMOND, VA., USA

The first step in managing customer expectations is to identify all stakeholders so you know whose expectations you need to manage. It also helps to interview at least some of the stakeholders in advance of a kickoff meeting. Meeting customers one-on-one gives you an opportunity to negotiate the agenda for the official meeting.

While preparing for individual conversations and the kickoff meeting, you must remember the order of importance to each party. For the project manager, priorities (in order) are scope, schedule and budget. On the other hand, the customer's priorities are budget, schedule and scope.

Determining what the customers need rather than what they want is the key to success. This will enable discussions to determine customer priorities on quality vs. speed and the availability of additional budget to bring the project to market as soon as possible.

While many people do well with this first stage, many fail to keep customers engaged after initial requirements are set. The kickoff meeting is also your opportunity to let the customers know your requirements for their involvement in phase reviews, status meetings, testing, implementation and post-project reviews. This involvement enables the customers to participate in all the decisions that affect the scope, schedule and budget. The results are customers who get what they need, when they need it and for a price they are willing to pay.

img

MICHAEL PETKO, PMP, PROJECT MANAGER, PALMA PROJECT PROFESSIONALS, CHARLOTTE, S.C., USA AND PRESIDENT, PMI METROLINA CHAPTER

The best practice I have found to be effective in ensuring that customer scope and quality expectations are met (realizing the inevitable time and cost constraints) is to link scope and its appropriate quality with schedule and budget as interdependent variables in the customer's mind.

By working through the development of scope, schedule and cost expectations in an iterative fashion and with customer involvement as appropriate, you can make the customer see that there are trade-offs among these three constraints. The rationale here is to move customers away from their initial position of, “I want it all, and I need it better, cheaper and faster.”

Project success depends on our ability to manage this “negotiation” before we develop the critical baselines and create the vision for acceptance of the project deliverables.

PM NETWORK | JANUARY 2003 | www.pmi.org

Like what you just read?

Log in or register for a free PMI account to get access 
to even more articles like this one.

Offer from our training partner

Advertisement

Offer from our training partner

Advertisement

Offer from our training partner

Advertisement