16 November 2026

After Energization: The Data Center Regulations That Can’t Be Enforced

By Joel Carboni, Ph.D., CSPP

Countries are setting energy and water requirements for data centers, but who ensures those commitments hold once facilities are running? Dr. Joel Carboni examines the gaps between regulation and accountability — and why sustainability obligations need to shape project decisions from the beginning.

data-center

In Consumer Reports, I read about John Steinbach, a retiree in Manassas, Virginia, who opened a $281 electric bill in January for the house he has lived in for nearly forty years. The month before, the same house cost him about $100. Manassas sits inside the densest data center corridor on earth. Across the regional grid that serves 65 million people from Chicago to Washington, the cost of securing power supply rose from $2.2 billion to $14.7 billion in a single year, with data centers responsible for close to two-thirds of the increase. Seven in ten Americans now oppose a data center in their own community. In the first three months of this year, communities blocked or delayed 75 projects worth about $130 billion.

The federal response arrived in March 2026 as a pledge in which seven companies committed to build, bring, or buy dedicated power for their new data centers. It was voluntary, with no enforcement provision and no reporting requirement. The United States will build more data center capacity this decade than any country except China, and its principal governance instrument is a promise.

Outside the United States, the countries that wrote binding rules are small ones, and their size is the reason they wrote them. They ran out of grid first. The rules they wrote range from renewable supply to water use to reporting. What most of them leave open is enforcement: who has the authority to act once a facility is built and running.

Rules in Ireland, a tax debate in Virginia

Data centers consumed 22% of Ireland's metered electricity in 2024 and roughly half of all demand in the Dublin region. Virginia's data centers draw more than 20% of that state's electricity today. These are the two densest data center corridors on earth, at nearly identical saturation, and they responded in opposite ways. Virginia is still debating its tax exemption, which cost the state $1.6 billion in forgone revenue in fiscal year 2025.

Ireland, after four years of an effective connection moratorium, published a policy in December 2025 that settles questions American regulators have not yet taken up. Every new data center must meet 80% of its annual electricity demand with additional renewable generation built inside Ireland, within six years of energization. Every facility must hold dispatchable generation or batteries matching its import capacity. The system operators can reject a site outright.

Ireland got to those rules first because Ireland is small enough to hit the wall first. A country of five million people cannot absorb hyperscale growth on rhetoric. The constraint forced precision. Large markets have been able to put precision off because the grid is big enough to hide the cost for a while. The bills arriving in Virginia this year are the end of that.

Scarcity in Singapore, overflow in Johor

Singapore froze new data center construction in 2019 when the facilities already drew 7% of national electricity. When it reopened in 2022, it converted scarcity into an approval instrument. The current allocation round grants capacity only to operators achieving power usage effectiveness (PUE) below 1.25 with at least half their energy from renewables, and the round was heavily oversubscribed, which means the standard costs Singapore nothing to hold.

The demand that failed to clear went across the strait to Johor, in Malaysia, which built one of the fastest-growing data center markets in the world on Singapore’s overflow and then discovered why the overflow existed. Johor now imposes a water use effectiveness ceiling of 1.8, matched to Singapore’s own standard, with a second test attached: a facility that meets the ceiling can still be refused if the water is unavailable at that location.

The second test carries a distinction most sustainability frameworks miss. Efficiency measures how well you use a resource. Availability measures whether the resource exists to be used. A facility can be best in class on the first measure and still exceed what a watershed or a grid can carry. Johor reached the distinction because its utilities forced the question. Most corporate net-zero programs have not reached it.

The EU chose disclosure. Chile never looked.

The European Union’s revised Energy Efficiency Directive requires every facility above 500 kilowatts to report energy and water performance to a central database each year. The first reporting cycle, completed in 2026, showed what disclosure delivers when nothing turns on it. Germany published a comprehensive dataset. The Dutch publication was widely judged incomplete, with data withheld wherever operators classified it as commercially sensitive, a classification the operators assigned themselves. A reporting obligation with no standards, approvals, or penalties produces little more than an incomplete database.

Chile shows the cost of having no way to measure at all. A Santiago environmental court revoked the license for a planned Google data center after documents showed its cooling towers would draw roughly the annual water consumption of the surrounding community. Reporters then found the permit should never have existed. The government, it turned out, had been letting data center builders bypass environmental assessment, and when asked, the environment ministry acknowledged that measuring a data center’s water consumption would require regulation the country did not have. The state had approved a facility whose primary impact it had no instrument to see.

Four regimes wrote a number. One named a person.

Ireland wrote 80%. Singapore wrote 1.25. Johor wrote 1.8. The EU wrote 500 kilowatts. Of the four, only Ireland named who can act when a running facility misses its number:  grid operators, whose statutory mandate is reliability. The one enforcement mechanism in existence belongs to an institution built to protect a different value.

Each number is a threshold. A threshold with no one standing at it is a disclosure. It changes what gets reported. It does not change what gets built or how it runs.

Policy sets the number. The project decides whether it is real.

Every obligation described above is executed at the project level. An 80% renewable supply requirement measured six years after energization is met, or missed, through procurement decisions, contract structures, and phasing choices made by a delivery team years before any regulator examines the outcome. A PUE ceiling is a design decision locked at approval. A water availability test is a siting decision made once.

The regulator sets the number. The project determines whether the number is real. The debate that fills the airtime, profit against planet, loses its meaning at a stage gate, because a gate review deals in specifics: a threshold, a measured value, and a person who either holds authority to act on the difference or does not.

PMI’s research shows the condition of that layer. In a 2026 survey of nearly 1,600 project professionals across 35 countries, 85% of sustainability executives said they were confident their organization could meet its sustainability goals. Among the PMO leaders who allocate resources and govern delivery, 43% agreed. Among the project professionals doing the work, 20% were extremely confident. Confidence is highest where the strategy is set and lowest where the work is done. In the same survey, 79% said sustainability positions their organization for long-term success, and 41% said it is integrated across projects and functions. The regimes described above are about to route legally binding obligations through the exact layer this data describes. The same research stream carries the other half of the ledger: PMI’s 2025 Project Success study found that projects carrying sustainability and social benefit themes achieve almost double the average rate of project success. The delivery layer is where the obligations land, where the confidence is thinnest, and where the measured value sits.

Every grievance in the backlash is a project impact. The electric bill in Manassas, the aquifer outside Santiago, the water Johor now meters before it approves anything, the noise and land disputes behind 75 blocked projects: each one originates in decisions made during a specific project’s initiation, design, and delivery. None of them is exotic, and none of them was unforeseeable.

The PMI® GPM® P5™ Standard for Sustainability in Project Management exists because impacts like these are identifiable before they occur. It examines a project’s effects on people, planet, and prosperity through its processes and its products, and a P5 Impact Analysis run at initiation surfaces every item on the grievance list before the first permit hearing. A Sustainability Management Plan then carries each impact through delivery with a threshold and a named owner.

Almost none of the projects now being blocked were built this way. Their impacts are being assessed anyway, in courtrooms, rate cases, and county hearings, after energization, by the people living with them. The Project Management Institute and GPM built the Certified Sustainable Project Professional (CSPP)™ certification for the practitioners who do this work at initiation instead. The impacts exist whether or not anyone assesses them. The communities blocking $130 billion in projects this year have concluded that if the delivery organizations will not run the analysis, they will.

The clocks are already running

Ireland’s six-year obligation has not yet come due for any facility approved under the new policy. Singapore’s standard binds only while allocation stays scarce. The EU’s enforcement package is promised for a later date. The American pledge has no date at all. Within a few years, the first facilities will miss their numbers, and each jurisdiction will learn whether it built a decision structure or a filing cabinet. The small countries wrote rules because their grids left them no choice. The large ones still have room, and the bills in Manassas show it running out.

Tags: Sustainability | Infrastructure | Green Project Management | Risk Management | Project Management

Make sustainability part of every project

Build the skills to assess environmental, social and economic impacts and apply sustainability from planning through delivery.

Quick answers to common questions about data center regulations and sustainability

What sustainability issues do data center regulations address?

Data center regulations can address electricity demand, renewable energy supply, energy efficiency, water consumption and environmental reporting. Requirements vary by jurisdiction: some establish conditions for approving facilities or connecting them to the grid, while others require operators to disclose performance. Their effectiveness depends on how requirements are measured, who has authority to act and what happens when a facility falls short.

Why isn’t data center energy efficiency enough to ensure sustainability?

Energy efficiency measures how effectively a data center uses electricity, but it does not establish whether the local grid can support the facility’s total demand. A highly efficient data center can still strain electricity supply, and water-efficient cooling can still draw more water than a watershed can sustain. Efficiency measures how well a facility uses a resource. Availability measures whether the resource exists at that location. A sustainability assessment needs both, along with total demand and the effects on surrounding communities.

How can project management help data centers meet sustainability requirements?

Project management helps translate sustainability requirements into siting, design, procurement and delivery decisions before a data center begins operating. Project teams can assess local energy and water constraints, build requirements into contracts and establish measurable targets, monitoring responsibilities and authority to address shortfalls. Planning the handover to operations helps carry those commitments beyond project completion.

The PMI® GPM® P5™ Standard for Sustainability in Project Managementdefines how to assess a project’s impacts on people, planet and prosperity across its processes and products. A P5 Impact Analysis run at initiation identifies those impacts while siting, design and procurement decisions can still change. The Certified Sustainable Project Professional (CSPP)™ certification verifies that practitioners can assess these impacts at initiation and manage them through the project life cycle.

Who enforces data center regulations?

Enforcement depends on the jurisdiction, and most rules do not name who can act once a facility is running. Ireland gives its grid operators authority over connection and renewable supply requirements. Singapore and Johor apply their energy and water standards at the approval stage. The European Union requires annual reporting, with enforcement measures still to come. The United States relies on a voluntary pledge with no enforcement provision.

About the Author

Joel Carboni, Ph.D., CSPP

Founder and President, GPM; Board Member, PMI-GPM Joint Venture

Dr. Joel Carboni is the founder and president of GPM and the architect of the standards, methods, and credentials behind Sustainable Project Management®, delivered through the PMI-GPM joint venture. He created the P5 Standard, the Sustainability Competence Standard, the Sustainable Project Management® Practice Guide, the Project Sustainability Reporting Guide and the Guide to Responsible Project Sponsorship. For over 30 years, his work has moved the profession in a different direction. A Forbes Business Council member and Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) contributor, he was shortlisted for the inaugural regenerative business award by Thinkers50 in 2025 for his book 'Becoming Regenerative'.

Read More from PMI Blog

    Related Insights

    Podcast

    How to Turn Sustainability Goals Into Project Decisions

    Learn how project leaders embed sustainability into project decisions, balancing cost, schedule, quality and long-term value.

    Listen Now - opens in a new tab

    You May Also Like

    Certification

    Certified Sustainable Project Professional (CSPP)™

    No experience required

    Lead resilient, sustainable projects that reduce risk, adapt to disruption and deliver measurable business value.

    Learn More
    Publication
    Free

    PMI® GPM® Practice Guide for Sustainability

    PMI Practice Guide

    Integrate sustainability into project delivery and governance to deliver measurable value for people, planet and prosperity.

    Learn More
    Publication
    Free

    The PMI® GPM® P5™ Standard for Sustainability

    The leading standard for sustainability, aligned with the PMBOK® Guide and global guidelines to drive measurable outcomes.

    Learn More